(NY Times) - An early Christian manuscript, including the only known text of the Gospel of Judas, has surfaced after 1,700 years, and it portrays Judas Iscariot not as a betrayer of Jesus but as his favored disciple and willing collaborator.
In this text, scholars reported yesterday, the account of events leading to the Crucifixion differs sharply from the four gospels in the New Testament. Here Jesus is said to entrust Judas with special knowledge and ask him to betray him to the Roman authorities. By doing so, he tells Judas, "you will exceed" the other disciples.
"You will be cursed by the other generations, and you will come to rule over them," Jesus confides to Judas in the document, which was made public at a news conference at the National Geographic Society in Washington.
Being a Jew, you all know the NT is not my book, so, I'll defer to my Christian friends to tell us what the religious significance of this finding may be for you. I would guess it is of value, but we'll see what you have to say. To me, from a historical perspective, a document like this from around the period when the NT was being canonized seems very interesting.
-MZ
The fundamentalist Christians look pretty stupid in light of this finding. Christianity has been officially discredited.
ReplyDeleteI am not a theologian, but I did graduate from a Catholic University and had to have 20 hours of college level theology courses (for what it is worth to you all).
ReplyDeleteI was taught very clearly that Christ knew that he had become a circus act.--"Turn water into wine." "Walk on the water." "Heal the sick, prophet."--His message was not sinking in, and he knew it, as did his father. He knew he had to become a martyr to start the spread of his word.
HE "CHOSE" A "FEW" JEWISH POWERS THAT BE TO CRUCIFY HIM, AS WELL AS PILATE. AND JUDAS WAS CHOSEN TO BETRAY HIM. He foresaw all of this plan in the garden, and the Son of Man was so terrified of what was to come, he asked his father to release him from his responsibility (some say he sweat blood).--It was denied, and things that were planned were set in motion.
A truly educated Christian knows this, and does not blame Jews or Pilate or Judas for anything, because they are indeed blameless.--THESE VERY SMALL NUMBER OF PEOPLE WERE CHOSEN, AND ACTUALLY HAD NO SAY IN THE MATTER!
In my opinion this theory changes nothing.
In the book of Colossians, Paul deals with something called "gnostism", which was a conglomeration of Greek phylosophy, Jewish ritualism and some Christian elements. What came out was a "mystery" religion that said salvation came by "secret" knowledge, that there was a "hierarchy" of spirits to be worshiped and "secret" rituals to be performed. It was NOT Christian or Judaism! There were many texts that were rejected because of this gnostic basis. The gospel of Judas is among them, interesting from an historical view, but, worthless from a Christian one.
ReplyDeleteInteresting the timing of the news release, after all the text has been around for a while! Attempt to discredit and weaken Christianity? Foolishness!
tmw
the new testament specifies the moment satan entered into judas - so essentially this scenario is true in the behaviors of man and the spirit of judas (satan) ruling over humanity. Yeshua said, "what you do, do quickly." this doesn't imply He made Judas do anything otherwise the whole free will idea would have to go out the window.
ReplyDeletehaving discussed judas in length with anybody who would listen - the real question is, at the moment he realized he betrayed an innocent man, did he repent? is that why he did himself in? was there forgiveness for him?
this is another attempt by the enemy to get christians to question their christianity. i will not see this movie and do not believe it will sway true christians in any manner.
if there was indeed a "gospel of judas" - there was also a very good reason it was left out of the holy bible. there are many books that didn't cut the muster and were left out for one reason or another. i'm not a theologian either, but know what i know what i know.
and to danabobanabobonehead - christianity needs more than a phony attempt to undermine us to be discredited. your anti-fundies are showing!
ReplyDeletePersonally, the ancient qualities of the text are very interesting to me. I don't expect that this finding will change anyone's religious views much, just as finding the Dead Sea scrolls had no impact on Jewish law. Yet, it does give us an interesting glimpse into the different deviations that existed from that early, formative era of Christian history.
ReplyDeletejudas is one of the reasons i try to keep eleven friends, maybe thirteen, but never twelve - you just never know, madze...
ReplyDeletethe davinci code implies that Jesus had a child with mary magdalene and the lineage of Christ goes on until the present. i won't see that movie either.
ReplyDeleteO.T. madze - see here for the custom avatar i've commissioned warren to create for fern:
http://freedomnowonline.blogspot.com/
it's an idea whose time has come.
I am not a Christian but if I were I would not accept any new additions to the Bible. These are second century works and may have no historical accuracy. Personally, the author sounds like an apologist for evil.
ReplyDeleteb.b. - the author is a minion of satan! sent to take our minds off the one true G-d and question our beliefs! Yeshua was tempted 40 days in the wilderness with EVERY temptation known to man and passed muster, so to speak. He said, "I have not come to abolish the law - I have come to complete it." there are no new additions to the bible - there can be none as the book of revelation, written approximately 70-90 a.d. states emphatically that those who add to or take away from will be cursed for eternity. the book was closed at that time and all we need to know are within its pages.
ReplyDeletewhether my jewish friends believe this or not is not for me to decide, but the new testament is just a testament to the old testament. i am an old testament christian which is why i find judaism so rich.
now, time for dana to get angry.
madze - are you going to tell us the peshach (passover) story this week in the special madze way of relating events? if so, i will draw an audience - i'd like to share it with my wednesday night kids also. you are so thoughtful.
ReplyDeleteOf course, nanc! I'll try and do it Tuesday night.
ReplyDeleteyou're not mad!
ReplyDeletesee this article for the other side of the story:
ReplyDeletehttp://reuters.myway.com/article/20060406/2006-04-06T205329Z_01_N06316777_RTRIDST_0_NEWS-RELIGION-JUDAS-DC.html
I'm still trying to figure out how Judas wrote a Gospel 350 years after he committed suicide.
ReplyDelete